Training versus competency
Training shows that a person was taught to perform a test. Competency assessment shows that they can perform it correctly, on an ongoing basis. CLIA requires both. Competency deficiencies are among the most frequently cited findings because the requirement applies to every person, for every test system, on a recurring schedule.
The six required procedures
For moderate and high complexity testing, CLIA lists six procedures that competency assessment must include (42 CFR 493.1413(b)(8)(i) moderate complexity; 42 CFR 493.1451(b)(8)(i) high complexity):
- Direct observation of routine patient test performance, including patient preparation, if applicable, and specimen handling, processing and testing.
- Monitoring the recording and reporting of test results.
- Review of intermediate test results or worksheets, quality control records, proficiency testing results and preventive maintenance records.
- Direct observation of performance of instrument maintenance and function checks.
- Assessment of test performance through testing previously analyzed specimens, internal blind testing samples or external proficiency testing samples.
- Assessment of problem-solving skills.
The CMS State Operations Manual, Appendix C explains that all six procedures apply to each test system a person performs, not to the person once overall. Where an element does not apply to a test, document why.
How often
- New testing personnel: at least semiannually during the first year the person tests patient specimens.
- After the first year: at least annually.
- When methods or instruments change: competency must be re-evaluated before the person reports patient results with the new method or instrument (42 CFR 493.1451(b)(8)(ii)–(iii) and the corresponding moderate complexity provision).
Who assesses and who is assessed
For moderate complexity, the technical consultant is responsible for evaluating testing personnel competency (42 CFR 493.1413). For high complexity, the technical supervisor is responsible, and may delegate assessment to a general supervisor who meets qualifications (42 CFR 493.1451). Competency of supervisors and consultants is assessed against their regulatory responsibilities, according to SOM Appendix C. The laboratory director remains responsible overall (42 CFR 493.1407, 42 CFR 493.1445) and must ensure delegation is documented. Laboratories must also have written policies for assessing employee competency (42 CFR 493.1235).
What a complete competency file contains
| Item | Example evidence |
|---|---|
| Qualifications | Diploma, transcript, license or certification for the role |
| Training | Signed training checklist per test before patient testing |
| Procedure acknowledgment | Signed read-and-understood for current procedure version |
| Six elements per test system | Observation forms, reviewed worksheets and QC, maintenance observation, blind or PT sample results, problem-solving quiz or case |
| Assessor and dates | Name, qualification and signature of the assessor, date completed |
| Remediation | Retraining and reassessment when performance is unacceptable |
Common competency gaps
- Six-month assessment missed for new hires.
- Only some test systems covered.
- Assessor not qualified or delegation not documented.
- Generic checklists that do not show the actual evidence reviewed.
- No reassessment after a new instrument went live.
- Competency of point-of-care testers outside the lab overlooked.
Tracking competency at scale
A spreadsheet can list due dates, but it cannot easily show what was observed, which evidence was reviewed, or whether retraining happened. A useful tracker links each person to the tests and instruments they perform, schedules all six elements per test system, assigns a qualified reviewer, stores the evidence and signatures, and flags anything due or overdue.
How myLabCompliance handles competency
According to mylabcompliance.io, the platform includes personnel qualification tracking with CLIA pathways, certification and license expiration alerts, training assignment and completion tracking, document upload and verification, personnel competency assessment, and competency dashboards. Assessments can be scheduled, evidence attached and completion tracked with the employee record, alongside the procedures, QC and PT records the assessment draws on. A qualified reviewer still has to perform and sign each assessment.
Related: proficiency testing tracking, document control, CAP survey preparation.
Frequently asked questions
What are the six CLIA competency elements?
Direct observation of routine testing; monitoring recording and reporting of results; review of worksheets, QC, PT and maintenance records; direct observation of instrument maintenance and function checks; testing previously analyzed, blind or PT samples; and assessment of problem-solving skills.
How often is competency assessed under CLIA?
At least semiannually during a person's first year of patient testing and at least annually after that, plus before reporting results on a new method or instrument.
Do all six elements apply to every test?
Per CMS guidance, the six procedures apply to each test system a person performs. If an element does not apply, document why.
Who can perform competency assessments?
The technical consultant for moderate complexity testing, and the technical supervisor for high complexity testing, who may delegate to a qualified general supervisor.
Does competency apply to waived testing?
The six-element requirement applies to moderate and high complexity testing. Waived testing must follow manufacturer instructions; many labs and accreditors still expect training and competency documentation.
See myLabCompliance with your own lab's workflow
Book a demo and bring the compliance task that takes the most of your week. Product details are on mylabcompliance.io.
Book a demoSources: 42 CFR 493.1235 · 42 CFR 493.1413 · 42 CFR 493.1451 · CMS State Operations Manual, Appendix C · 42 CFR Part 493 (eCFR)
This page is general information about laboratory regulations, not legal or regulatory advice. Confirm current requirements with CMS, your state agency, and your accrediting organization.